You’ve heard the stories. Rumours. LEGENDS! Maybe it was a braggadocious social post by a Realtor®, or perhaps a friend talking about how they sold their home with double-digit offers. But most likely, you’ve heard it from a dejected buyer, complaining about how they can’t seem to win a competitive offer situation—there are far more of those people than you might think.
If you’re considering buying a two-apartment home in St. John’s, it’s time to take a serious look at what’s happening in the market so that you don’t become one of those frustrated buyers, getting increasingly emotional with every lost opportunity. And if you have one or more rental properties in your investment portfolio, the information below goes beyond the anecdotal, providing quantifiable data you should consider when evaluating your investments.
2024 Market Performance: The Numbers Speak for Themselves
Based on recent MLS data, 2024 has been an incredibly competitive year for two-apartment homes in St. John’s—perhaps more than many realize!
Here are some key insights from last year’s sales:
A total of 414 two-apartment homes were sold in St. John’s in 2024.
68% of those homes sold above asking price—a clear indicator of strong demand.
The highest over-asking sale in this category was 31.3% above asking, meaning the seller walked away with an extra $72,100 over list price.
The average over-asking sale resulted in a sale-to-list price ratio of 106%, meaning sellers received an average of 6% more than their asking price in competitive situations.
Speed was a factor: Homes that sold above asking spent an average of just 33.1 days on the market, while those that sold at or below asking took significantly longer at 51.3 days.
The median price per square foot was $171.25, reflecting a 25% increase over the five-year median value of $137.27 and a 12% increase year over year from 2023.
Median price per square foot of over-asking properties was $175.
2025 Trends: The Market Is Only Getting Hotter
While we are only in February, the data suggests that the two-apartment market in St. John’s is getting even more competitive:
34 two-apartment home sales have been recorded so far in 2025.
70% of these sales have gone over asking price, a slight increase from 2024’s already high 68%.
For properties selling at or over asking, the average sale-to-list ratio is 111%, with a median of 114%.
The median price per square foot has increased to $177.51, marking a 3.6% rise from 2024.
For competitive sales over asking, the median price per square foot is now $181.86, a 4% increase for the most desirable two-apartment properties.
The median sale price for two-apartment homes that sold over asking has jumped 9.7%, from $399,450 in 2024 to $438,500 in early 2025.
With market supply at historically low levels and incredibly strong demand driven by homeowners seeking to offset living costs and investors recognizing the high ROI opportunities, 2025 is shaping up to be a record-breaking year for two-apartment homes in St. John’s.
How Does This Compare to the Single-Family Home Market?
The single-family home market is also highly competitive but not as intense as the two-apartment sector:
1,118 single-family homes were sold in St. John’s in 2024.
52% of these homes sold above asking price.
The highest over-asking sale was a heritage home on Rennies Mill Road, which sold for $1,200,000—60% over its $749,900 list price.
The average over-asking sale resulted in a 106% sale-to-list price ratio, mirroring the two-apartment market.
Homes that sold above asking spent an average of 34.0 days on the market, while those that sold at or below asking took 52.3 days.
What This Means for Buyers and Sellers
Buyers: Be Prepared to Act Quickly
Expect competition—many homes are selling for well over asking price.
Get pre-approved for your mortgage so you can move quickly.
Work with an experienced Realtor® who understands the fast-paced nature of this market.
Be ready to submit strong, competitive offers, potentially with fewer conditions.
Sellers: Now Could Be the Best Time to Cash In
Demand is high, and supply is limited. Listing now could allow you to capitalize on high buyer interest.
Strategic pricing and property preparation matter. Proper staging, minor upgrades, and competitive pricing can maximize your return.
Investors should consider whether to sell or hold. With rising rents and increasing home values, now is an excellent time to reassess your portfolio.
Final Thoughts
The two-apartment home market in St. John’s is experiencing unprecedented demand, and the numbers prove it. Whether you’re a buyer looking to secure a property that can help offset living costs, or an investor evaluating the best time to buy or sell, understanding the current market dynamics is crucial.
With over 15 years of experience as a full-time professional Realtor®, I have been consistently recognized for my service and sales excellence, and, for the past two years, I have held the title of top-performing solo agent in St. John's for Keller Williams Platinum Realty. With my experience and knowledge of the market on your side, you can feel confident in the decisions you make about your real estate. Here’s what one of my clients had to say:
“Andrew is the epitome of professionalism! He is always prepared, he always makes time and he always dedicates 100% energy to his clients. If you are looking for someone who will go well beyond the norm, Andrew will not disappoint." - Lynn Squires
Reach out today to chat about keeping you ahead in such a fast paced and aggressive housing market.